A reviewer identified themselves to the author in a small field

Popularity Index: 4 Updated at 2026-10-11 09:20 UTC

Sites

Related Topics

The reviewer asked for a citation to their own work Serving as a reviewer while your own paper sits in the same journal's queue Single-blind vs double-blind review: does hiding author names change who gets in? Why reviewers disagree so violently on the same manuscript Getting a paper to review that sits outside your field by one step Reviewers picked for prestige rather than expertise in the exact method Reviewing a revised manuscript: do you re-read the whole thing? How long should a referee report take to write? Should early career researchers review papers at all? The unwritten rule against reviewing a direct competitor's grant

Hot Categories

Featured Categories