Skip to content

Historical controversies - Category Home

Historical controversies - Topics

Historical figures on the losing side of a war get thinner documentation and stranger legends. The trap of treating denial as one side of a balanced debate Jaspers's Axial Age claims a simultaneous breakthrough in four regions — does the chronology hold? Fields of history that began as critiques are now taught as their own subdisciplines. Excavating a battle site usually finds less than the chronicle promised The Late Bronze Age collapse took down almost every palace system within two generations Stonehenge's bluestones were dragged 250 km and nobody agrees why Was the Renaissance a real break with the Middle Ages? Why the bombing of Hiroshima keeps being re-argued by historians Great Zimbabwe and the colonial refusal to credit African builders Slavery's role in early capitalism argued up by new economic historians How do you design a memorial for an event with no agreed death toll? Is there any archaeological trace of the Exodus? What do you do when a student's family denies the history you are teaching? Lost advanced civilization claims always need a cover-up Did the Industrial Revolution raise living standards for workers? Piltdown Man and the decades it took to expose a hoax Did Easter Island society collapse or adapt? An outline of history cannot show debate among historians unless it flags the disputes. Where do I find reviews of a new historical work written by specialists rather than newspapers? Tracking history awards year by year shows which subjects the profession is rewarding now. Why historians now doubt the Black Death was uniformly bubonic The Historikerstreit and whether the Nazi past could be compared Did the Mycenaean palaces fall to invaders or to systems collapse? Was late antiquity a transformation or just a polite word for collapse? The seventeenth-century crisis debate: one general crisis or a pile of unrelated local famines? Who burned the Library of Alexandria is still argued The Fischer controversy over German war guilt in 1914 What do you do with a monument to someone whose crimes were proven after the dedication? The Pirenne thesis and the claim that Arab conquests did not end antiquity The Goldhagen debate over whether ordinary Germans were willing executioners Göbekli Tepe was built by hunter-gatherers and it broke the farming-first story