Skip to content

Historical methodology - Category Home

Historical methodology - Topics

Why do the fields of history keep multiplying while departments stay the same size? The narrator who claims to be neutral is still making choices about order Do the fields of history overlap so much that specializing early is a mistake? The difference between a historical method and a habit of reading Selection rules: how do you decide which cases are comparable before you compare them? What makes a historical method testable by someone else? Source criticism as a set of rules rather than a mood Why the historical method you choose decides which past you can see Does the philosophy of history still matter to working historians? How the linguistic turn divided historians in the 1980s Why laws of history keep failing the test of the next century Why comparative historians have to argue for comparability before they compare Historians' objections to counterfactual history and the case for ignoring them Methodological principle: never build a big claim on a single uncorroborated source Why every historian should say how they would know they were wrong How do you narrate a period that had no clear beginning or end? What does it mean to say an event was bound to happen? Why comparing two countries is easier to write than to justify What makes a document authentic is not the handwriting The methodological rule that puts the burden of proof on the surprising claim Why fitting neatly into a theory is not evidence in history Most-similar design in comparative history: picking two cases that differ in one thing What makes one interpretation better than another if both fit the documents? How much theory does a historical argument actually need? Choosing where to begin a narrative decides what counts as the cause If half of the survey goes to the last hundred years the earlier centuries get four minutes each How do you organize a one-semester world history course without starting at agriculture? The units problem: are you comparing nations or regions or systems? The three-age system was invented to sort museum cabinets not to explain anything Free will and historical explanation: blaming a person versus explaining a system Flint tools are classified by how they were struck not by what they were for External criticism asks whether the document is what it claims to be