Skip to content

Sagely counsel - Category Home

Sagely counsel - Topics

Diogenes the Cynic answered every serious question with an insult Solomon's advice to his son opens Proverbs: how much of it is actually about money Why are so many sages credited with answers they probably never gave Can advice be given without the giver's own life vouching for it Which sage in history was executed by the authorities and what does that say Polonius gives advice he cannot follow: the maxim-spewing fool Asking a wise elder for advice is not the same as asking an expert The best counselors answer a question with a question The judgment of the two harlots and the living child is a trick not a law The goddess of wisdom so rarely has children of her own Why good mentors ask questions instead of handing out answers Solomon and the queen of Sheba: a queen testing a king with riddles The same advice is sound from one friend and destructive from another because discernment reads the source The counselor who says I don't know may be the only honest one in the room Monastic silence is not the absence of speech but a training in when to speak The sagacious advisor is the one whose silence is also advice Why spiritual directors treat advice as a last resort Atticus Finch loses the case and his children learn more from that than from winning Job's friends give orthodox answers and are told they spoke wrongly of God Unsolicited counsel is almost always rejected even when it is correct Confession vs therapy vs asking your grandmother: three settings for receiving counsel When someone asks what should I do they often want permission rather than analysis The elder says wait: how do you tell patience from avoidance in the advice you get How do you grade a student in a wisdom course when the exam is their life Advice that begins with your situation is never transferable to anyone else Kings kept counselors who flattered and prophets who didn't The Delphic oracle told Oedipus he would kill his father: counsel that caused the outcome What makes a piece of advice ethical rather than merely efficient Ask a clarifying question about the facts before accusing anyone of wrongdoing in an ethics case