Skip to content

Critical judgment - Category Home

Critical judgment - Topics

Why AI-generated photos are now the hardest part of fact-checking a breaking news story Good judgment is less about being right once and more about revising when the evidence turns AlphaGo's move 37 looked creative but carried no intention Checking where a quotation actually comes from is now a two-minute job that almost nobody does A slogan tells you what to feel and advice tells you what to do next which is why slogans win Intelligence does not immunize anyone against motivated reasoning: it just supplies better excuses How to tell whether a viral missing-person post has been recycled from years ago Why a screenshot of a chat message is never proof on its own Attaching a line to Lincoln or Churchill is how a weak claim borrows a strong voice Spotting an ad hominem is easy and noticing when you are the one using one is the hard part Groupthink destroyed NASA's Challenger decision chain Checking a health claim a relative forwarded before repeating it to anyone else When a charity appeal asks for money through a personal bank account Telling good judgment from luck means checking the process and not only the outcome Judging whether a landlord's verbal promise about repairs is worth anything Prudential judgment needs a probability estimate and a value estimate and people constantly conflate the two Reading a company's own press release about its safety record Most corporate foresight units die of irrelevance when nobody links their scenarios to the capital budget Juries judge facts and judges judge law because the two kinds of judgment fail in different ways An aphorism that no case could contradict is a mood rather than a claim Critical judgment in the news means separating what a source knows firsthand from what it repeats Telling a paid review apart from one written by someone who actually bought the thing Deciding whether a headline's percentage actually means what the headline says The straw man is rarely deliberate: people argue with the version of your view they can beat Steelmanning the other side is the fastest way to find out whether your own case holds up Critical judgment asks what evidence would falsify the claim before you accept it Discernment is not suspicion: the suspicious person finds fault everywhere and distinguishes nothing Judging a used car listing when the seller will not meet at the registered address Hindsight bias makes every past surprise look like something we should have seen coming Base rates get ignored because one vivid story feels like more evidence than a statistic Can you understand an argument you reject and does that count as wisdom Anecdotes beat statistics in our heads because evolution tuned us for local gossip and not for samples