Skip to content

Philosophical debates - Category Home

Philosophical debates - Topics

Why are intuitions treated as evidence in philosophy but not in the sciences? How did the extended cognition debate shift from metaphysics to methodology? What exactly is an intuition pump and why do critics call it cheating? Is a private language even possible? Is the scientific realism debate really about inference to the best explanation? Why does philosophical inquiry rarely end in agreement the way a proof does? Why does the problem of universals keep returning in new vocabulary? Why do the sides in the moral realism debate keep talking past each other? What exactly divides deflationists from inflationists about truth? What separates a reason for acting from a cause of acting? Why does the method of cases get called armchair psychology? Where does the mind-body problem stand after functionalism and the hard problem? Why did the debate about grounding turn into a fight over what explanation is? Why do some philosophers want to abolish the boundaries between branches entirely? Is continental philosophy's hostility to naturalism a position or a temperament? Do video games count as art or is that the wrong question? Is meaning in the speaker's head or in the community that uses the word? What separates the two camps in the dispute over phenomenal and access consciousness? Did Camus belong to existentialism or spend his career denying it? Has the problem of evil shifted from a logical problem to an evidential one? T. M. Scanlon's buck-passing account of value and the objections to it Who is on each side of the dispute over whether reasons can be causes? Why is deconstruction so often mistaken for the claim that anything goes? Should history be written for the needs of the present? Should we believe in electrons we can never observe? Is the identity theory of mind dead or just renamed physicalism? What does virtue ethics actually offer as a decision procedure? Why has simulation theory lost ground to theory-theory in mindreading? How do philosophical traditions get named by their enemies rather than by their members? How do rival philosophical schools end up arguing about the same problem in incompatible vocabularies? Is there a real moral difference between killing someone and letting them die? How much should an artist's intentions count when we interpret the work?